Activism and Alienation – Why I Feel Excluded

I’ve seen a trend over the years and it’s not a good one: activism is increasingly becoming a bubble, an echo-chamber where the only people listening are fellow activists.

There are reasons for this and one of the most telling ones is that the message is not reaching the audience. How often do you read an article or listen to a speech by an activist? If you’re not one yourself, the answer is probably close to never.

The big question is why?

For me (and I suspect for others too) there are a couple of elephant-in-the-room type problems. Activists seem to speak a different language, they bombard us with academic jargon and unfamiliar terms. Even the words that we recognize have subtle shifts in meaning so that understanding remains elusive. And then if we don’t use their preferred terminology or accept all of their ideological rhetoric as the gospel truth we get attacked. To put it simply, we are excluded.

What a great way to convince people to listen to you! Yes, that is sarcasm.

With far too many activists it’s a case of “my way or the highway”. You either interact with them entirely on their terms or you get bullied into submission or retreat. And most people won’t submit, so the audience dwindles until the only ones left are those who echo the activist’s ideology.

What’s the point of being an activist, of fighting for social justice, if in the end you are only preaching to the choir? The congregation has gotten fed up with your hellfire and brimstone and the pews are empty.

You’ll notice the overt religious imagery I’m using here. That’s deliberate. Running into an activist has a lot in common with running into a fundamentalist preacher. They are so convinced of the rightness of their beliefs that to question them in any way brings down their full wrath.

 

 

Last weekend there were the largest protest marches in US history, responding to the inauguration of Donald Trump as President. These protests were instigated by women in response to fears about the actions and intentions of the new administration.

But what were the majority of posts I saw on Facebook saying? Were they talking about the historic scale of the opposition? About the importance of standing up for rights that are visibly under threat?

No, the majority of posts I saw were basically saying that the majority of those protesting did not have valid concerns, that they should be ignored for not doing things the way the activists would prefer them to.

That because they were marching for reasons that meant something important to them as individuals but did not explicitly seek to include other groups they were somehow hostile to those other groups.

Now I’m not saying that ignorance and privilege are right or fair. But they exist. And unless activists engage with these people they will continue to exist. Shaming women who believe that sexual assault is wrong and got behind the “pussyhat” because “not all women have a vagina” is a shitty thing to do. For a lot of women the vagina (and associated organs) is something they strongly identify with as symbolic of their gender. Denouncing this as binary gender essentialism, or reducing people to their genitals doesn’t change the way so many women feel. It might not align with the activist’s beliefs but that doesn’t make it less real.

The culture of calling out and shaming people is wrong. It’s the tactics of the oppressor, the bully, of those we are trying to fight. It doesn’t advance the cause of understanding or acceptance. It’s just asking for them to turn around, say “Fuck you!” and decide you’re irrelevant. You might get kudos from fellow activists for being “on-message” but you’ve been counterproductive. You’ve stopped someone from listening to you before you even explain your point.

Bullying people into complying with your wishes and demands breeds resentment and opposition. If they comply they do so under duress, and as soon as they feel they are no longer under scrutiny they will actively undermine you. It’s about hearts and minds, not about coercing people by threat.

If we truly want to achieve equality, acceptance, understanding and all the other good stuff we need people to come to us willingly. Every person we alienate is a potential opponent, every person we support is a potential ally. We have a lot of opponents and some of them are very powerful. We need allies and supporters. We need to include them, not shame them and drive them away. Once they’re in the door we can educate them, teach them why some of the things they do might be problematic.

I’ve stopped interacting with activists online. It’s a toxic environment, like traversing a minefield where the slightest mis-step leaves you injured. I’m excluded, and I’m saying this as an autistic trans woman who ought to be feeling supported by rights activism. But I don’t feel supported. I feel threatened, unsafe in those spaces. I feel I have to watch every word I say or write, second-guess everything. And I’m not willing to do that – it takes energy I can’t spare to avoid any mistake that will bury me under an avalanche of bullying verbal assault.

I support many of the aims of activism for rights, but too many of the tactics are actively dangerous to my health and well-being. That’s why I am alienated. That’s why I am excluded. That’s what activism is getting wrong, for me and for others.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Activism and Alienation – Why I Feel Excluded

  1. So true. I am on a journey to learn about my son who has Autism as an NT parent. I have been advised to seek the views of adults with Autism to help me understand his point of view. What I found online was abuse for using the wrong terminology and it seems just for daring to be NT whilst having a child with Autism. One comment read “I hate fucking NT parents” i’ve had to stop listening and walk away from the autism activists. It saddens me TBH.

    • I’ve seen too much of that myself. I really don’t know how they think they are helping anybody by being abusive like that.

      It’s completely unreasonable to expect someone to use particular terminology when it’s all so new to them. Heck, it took me a long time to learn the common terms for different autism-related things like “stimming” or “sensory seeking”.

      I think I was lucky to first encounter a group of autistic people who were genuinely interested in educating and helping foster understanding. Because since then I have run into a lot who are self-righteous and intolerant.

      When all you want is help and advice so you can better understand and help your child (something nobody should be able to fault) that kind of bullying must give you reason to worry about how your son will be treated by his supposed autistic peers.

      I hope you have also encountered autistic advocates who are helpful and supportive, and that you have been able to find the information you need. If not, please feel free to contact me with any questions and I’ll do my best to answer them or point you in the direction of resources.

      Thank you for taking the time to tell me your experiences.

  2. Alex, wow, thank you!! Once again you have framed my thoughts beautifully, given me a place to start a conversation with people I love. So many of these things are difficult for me to explain because I become agitated and anxious during the attempt to describe my feelings of exclusion. But when I can point someone to your blog, it gives me a place to start, a third-party to defend, and become less emotionally involved in the story I’m telling, at least long enough for the story to start.

    Thank you.

    • Thank you ClaireElaine. From what you and others have said to me it seems there are quite a few of us who find it triggering to witness that aggressive, confrontational approach.

      Like you I find my anxiety levels rise rapidly until I can’t interact, which means I’m excluded. I believe it should be a priority for activists to accommodate the needs of those they say they are trying to support.

I'd love to hear your thoughts on this.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s